An independent Wyoming judiciary safeguards the rights of all

We are past presidents of the Wyoming State Bar, writing to support an independent judiciary, the rule of law and our constitutional system. It is reasonable to disagree with court decisions—half the people leaving a courtroom generally do. Constructive, respectful debate is a necessary part of democracy. But personal attacks on judges are inappropriate and dangerous.

Judges must be free from improper influence or political pressure so they can fairly apply the law based on the facts and the Constitution. This independence protects everyone’s rights and public confidence in our courts. The Wyoming Constitution separates powers among the legislative, executive and judicial branches, each with distinct roles. The judiciary’s role is to interpret and apply the law, and respecting that role—whether or not we like a result—is vital to stable government.

Judicial independence does not shield judges from accountability; accountability must come through the Constitution’s established processes, including the voters’ critical role in retention votes. Intimidation, personal attacks, attempts to change our merit selection system and efforts to undermine the courts do not create accountability; they erode confidence in justice and the rule of law.

An independent judiciary safeguards the rights of all Wyoming citizens and strengthens trust in our legal system. We will continue to support these principles in service to the people of Wyoming.