Police raids on two jewellery stores in North Texas last week were meant to shut down a fraud operation. What they really exposed was something broader and more uncomfortable: for hundreds of elderly victims, the biggest mistake was not buying gold, but trusting the wrong way to hold it.
The year-long investigation, led by the Collin County Sheriff’s Office with federal support, culminated in coordinated raids on Tilak Jewelers in Irving and Saima Jewelers in Frisco. Authorities say the stores were part of a laundering chain for what has become known as the “gold bar scam”, in which seniors were persuaded to liquidate savings, buy physical gold, and hand it to couriers posing as federal agents. The gold was then melted into jewellery and resold or smuggled out of the country.
More than $55m has been stolen statewide, including over $7m from around 200 victims in Collin County alone. Only about $400,000 has been recovered so far. One victim, investigators say, lost more than $1m in cash.
“You call Collin County and you go to defraud our citizens, we’re going to come get you, that’s just the bottom line,” Sheriff Jim Skinner said as officers hauled away cash and gold in a Brinks armoured truck.
But while law enforcement focuses on arrests and asset seizures, analysts are pointing to a quieter lesson buried inside the case: custody risk.
“Hundreds of victims lost their life savings not because they made a bad investment choice, but because of where and how they kept their gold,” Sam Bourgi, senior analyst at InvestorsObserver, said.
Gold prices have surged in 2026 as investors look for shelter from inflation, geopolitical shocks and market volatility. Fraud has surged with them. AI-driven impersonation scams, romance fraud and bogus metals offers are now routine. Yet, as the Texas case shows, the most destructive schemes are often the simplest: convincing people to physically hand over their assets.
Bourgi argued that most investors understand market risk but underestimate what happens once assets leave regulated systems.
“If you have significant liquid assets – whether in savings, CDs, or cash – you face two distinct risks. The first is market risk, which is well-understood. The second is custody risk, which most people never discuss,” he said.
In the Texas scam, criminals exploited that blind spot. Victims were told to buy gold precisely because it could be moved quietly, melted quickly and erased from paper trails. The recovery numbers tell the story.
“Of the $55 million stolen, only $400,000 has been recovered. That’s a 0.7% recovery rate,” Bourgi said. “If you lose $100,000 in a stock market crash, you can rebuild it over time. If you hand $100,000 in physical gold to a criminal, it’s gone – melted down and resold before you realize what happened.”
None of this, he stresses, is an argument against gold itself. It’s an argument against casual custody.
“If you’re considering precious metals as part of your asset allocation, ask yourself one question: where will this asset sit?” Bourgi said.
Keeping gold at home may feel empowering, but it concentrates risk. Professional vault storage, he argues, changes the equation entirely.
“Gold held through allocated storage accounts sits in insured, climate-controlled facilities with 24/7 security. You cannot hand it to a stranger. You cannot be pressured into transferring it verbally. Recovery is guaranteed by insurance and institutional oversight.”
The arithmetic, in his view, is simple.
“A small annual custody fee … purchases protection worth far more than the cost.”
Federal authorities have been blunt about the warning signs. The Federal Trade Commission has repeatedly said no government agency will ever demand secrecy, instruct someone to buy gold, or send couriers to collect assets. Anyone who does is running a scam.
Yet the Texas raids show how effective fear still is, especially when paired with physical assets that sit outside the safeguards of the financial system.
“The criminals in this case understood one thing clearly: physical assets in unprotected spaces are easier to steal than digital assets in regulated systems,” Bourgi said. “It’s time you understood it too.”
The latest news in your social feeds
Subscribe to our social media platforms to stay tuned